How to Report your Submissions (individual subscribers only)

A Note about Privacy: Your right to privacy is important to us. Read our Privacy Policy and contact us with any concerns.

Getting Started

You can use the "Report Submission/Response" link (below the cover art) from any of our listings (recommended), or you can access the report response tool directly.

Please obey the following rules:
(1) Only report your own submissions. (If you are an editor of a publication listed with us, you may not report any submissions for your listing.)
(2) Honestly report your rejections as well as acceptances to avoid skewing the response statistics we maintain for all users of this site.
(3) Report a submission per piece (not a submission per batch of pieces).

Selecting a Market

You will need to select the market from your search results (if you used a "Report Submission/Response" link from a listing, you will skip this step). Please be aware that we list many projects with similar titles. Be sure to report your submissions under the correct listing. Using the "Report Submission/Response" link from the listing helps avoid any confusion. If the market isn't listed, let us know about it and we will add it (if it qualifies for a listing) as soon as possible.

Entering Dates

You will need to enter pertinent dates in US format (MM/DD/YY) or through the drop-down calendar.

Sent date: For all submissions, enter the date you sent the submission.

Received date:

  • If you have received a response, then enter the date you received a response.
  • If you are entering a withdrawal or lost/never responded submission, then enter the date you withdrew the piece or the date you gave up waiting for a response.
  • If you are still waiting on a response and are not reporting it as lost/never responded, then leave the Date Received field blank.

Acknowledged date: Optionally, you can enter the date you received acknowledgment of your submission.

Date Queried: If you have sent the editor a query about this submission, you may enter the date in this field.

Submission Status

You can enter the following submissions statuses:

  • Pending response: When you have not yet heard a response on a submission. You will be able to update the status of this submission as needed through your Submission Tracker.
  • Acceptance: Congratulations! Your piece has been accepted for publication.
  • Rejection: Optionally, you may indicate one of the following:
    • Form rejection
    • Personal rejection (It is up to you to determine when a rejection is personal and when it is a form. As a rule of thumb, if the rejection specifically discusses or critiques the work you submitted, then it is a personal rejection.)
  • Lost/Returned: When you have learned that your submission has been lost (i.e., never received) or returned to you (i.e., the editor is not reading submissions now). You will need to enter the date you discovered that your submission was lost or returned as the date of response. If you resubmit the same piece to this market, please enter the resubmission as a separate report.
  • Never responded: When you have given up waiting for a response. The system will not let you use this status if it is still within a normal period of time for that market to respond. You will need to enter the date you gave up waiting as the date of response. If you resubmit the same piece to this market, please enter the resubmission as a separate report.
  • Withdrawal: When you have contacted the editors to withdraw a piece from consideration, generally because it was accepted elsewhere first. Please do not abuse this option; if your piece was actually rejected, do not mark it as "withdrawn" as that significantly skews the statistics for everyone else. You will need to enter the date you withdrew the piece as the date of response.

In addition to Submission Status, you can indicate the following:

  • Shortlisted: Use when you have learned that your submission has been shortlisted. This is only available as an option for Pending responses and Rejections.
  • Rewrite Requested: Use when the editor has specifically asked you to rewrite/rework the piece and resubmit it. With rewrite requests, we prefer you to enter the rewritten piece as a separate submission. This is only available as an option for Rejections.

What Piece did you submit?

You will need to select the title(s) from your "pieces list".

Note When submitting Collections or Chapbooks, select the title of the collection or chapbook as the Piece; please do not select each individual piece in the collection/chapbook. However, if you are submitting multiple individual pieces, please do select each piece being submitted.

Adding a piece: If the title isn't already in your "pieces list," you can add it either by using the "I need to add a piece to my list" option (be sure to click the "Add and Continue" button after entering the information, and then finish entering the details of the submission), or by going to your List of Pieces and adding the piece there.

Submitting multiple pieces at once: If you are submitting more than one piece to the same market with the exact same dates and other details, you can choose the "multiple pieces were sent together" option and use ctrl-click (cmd-click on Macs) to select each title from your list, or you can submit them individually if you prefer or if you don't meet all the criteria for the multiple pieces option.

How did you submit it?

Enter one of the following under Submission Method:

  • Electronic: Any type of electronic submission, such as email or online forms.
  • Postal: A physical submission sent through the mail.
  • Submission Manager: A submission sent via a third-party submission manager.

Last Step: Submitting the Form

Finally, submit the information, and it will automatically be included in our records and in your personal Submissions Tracker. Be sure that you receive confirmation of the submission report, and check for any alerts on the page indicating an entry error.


How to use your Submissions Tracker

Your personal Submissions Tracker includes information on all the submissions — pending and completed — that you've reported to us.

Sorting and filtering your report

You can filter your report by:

  • Submission status
  • Piece
  • Market
  • Year of submission

You can choose how to sort your list by using the "Sort by" setting, and you can choose how many to display at a time using the "Rows per page" setting.
If the filter form is taking up too much space, use the "Auto-hide" option. If you want to have your settings remembered indefinitely, be sure to use the "Save settings" option.

Updating your submission entries

If you have either need to update a submission's status or you need to correct a mistake, you can use the "Update" link in that submission's row on your report. Editing the information is exactly the same as entering a new submission, except the previous information is pre-filled.

Updating multiple entries: If you sent multiple pieces to a market at the same time and you would like to update them in bulk instead of singly, use the "Update" link in the row for any submission that you sent in that batch. The form will include the other pieces that you sent at the same. Check the box for each piece that received the same response, and click "Update." If some of your pieces were rejected and others accepted, you will need to complete this process twice: once for the ones rejected and once for the ones accepted.

Knowing when to query

For your pending submissions, your report displays how many days have passed since you sent the submission, how many days on average it takes for that market to respond (if we have the information), and the editor's requested minimum number of days that should pass before you send a query (if known).

Pending responses will also be color coded to help you determine when it might be appropriate to query the editor or update the status of the submission.

It is probably too early to send a query at this point.
Either the editors have requested no queries or they do not respond to all submissions (see their guidelines for details). It may be appropriate to change the status to "Rejected" or "Never Responded" at this point.
It may be appropriate to send a query on the status of your submission at this point. Always check guidelines before querying.

Deleting a submission entry

Please don't delete a submission entry unless it is an accidental entry or you have very good reason to do so. Remember that the submissions information you submit is included in the statistics we maintain. Deleting a submission affects that data and can give other members misleading information (such as an inflated acceptance percentage). If you don't want to see your rejections, please use the filtering options outlined above.

Archiving your Submissions

Although we have never lost anyone's submissions information, we cannot guarantee that it will never happen, and we highly recommend that you archive your submissions tracker regularly. We provide basic "Export to Excel/CSV" support specifically for this purpose.


We hope this information has helped you understand how to report and track your submissions. If you have any suggestions on how we can improve this guide, please let us know.

Report a Submission OR Go to your Submissions Tracker